Were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay
This is direct criticism against the generals, and evidence that the soldiers were ‘lions led by donkeys’ the commander-in-cheif generals of the british army during the first world war were sir john french (1915) and sir douglas haig (915 onwards. How accurate is the statement ‘lions led by donkeys’ in relation to british soldiers and generals of the first world war in the first world war, more men died than in any other war before. 20,000 british soldiers died in one day in the battle of the somme as they were repetitively sent over and over in waves of direct frontal attack against the german lines directly opposite. History-lions led by donkeys essay sample written by alan clark a politician in the 1960s this quotation describes the leadership of the british military and their strategies used in the great war it suggests that soldiers fighting in the world war were brave and courageous as he refers to them as lions.
Were the british soldiers of the western front ‘lions led by donkeys’ (john laffin) the traditional answer to this question is simply yes the scale of human devastation during world war one has often been blamed on incompetent leadership however more recent analysis of the nature of warfare and how the war was led has. Ever since the first world war the quote 'lions led by donkeys' has been used to describe the british army, and refers to the brave troops as 'lions' that are being led by stupid 'donkey' generals. Essay on we were soldiers 1091 words 5 pages we were soldiers question were the british soldiers 'lions led by donkeys' has been an ongoing debate since the end of the war a war which is dominated by images of bloody battles such as the somme and passchendaele - futile frontal attacks against the machine guns more about essay on.
It was led by men who, if not military geniuses, were at least thoroughly competent commanders the victory in 1918 was the payoff the 'lions led by donkeys' tag should be dismissed for what it. Lions led by donkeys was a phrase used to describe the british infantry of the first world war and to condemn the generals who commanded them the contention is that the brave soldiers (lions) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders (donkeys) at the battle of the somme. Lions led by donkeys ww1 essay the question were the british soldiers 'lions led by donkeys' has been an ongoing debate since the end of the war a war which is dominated by images of bloody battles such as the somme and passchendaele - futile frontal attacks against the machine guns. Related documents: essay on the british army were lions led by donkeys british: british empire and main army essay british leave philadelphia as a consequence of the french involvement in the war, the british government decided to abandon philadelphia and concentrate their main army at new york.
The view of lions led by donkeys is one that was brought about after the war, reinforced by ajp taylor, and ultimately cemented in the british public's mind by black adder (if you don't believe me, watch black adder and you'll see exactly what i mean. 1 lions led by donkeys this is an article by professor peter simkin, challenging the idea that great war generals were incompetent 2 lions led by donkeys this is a similar article to the one above and is by dr gary sheffield, another leading ww1 historian. The lions were not led by donkeys the first world war was a conflict of gangrene, gas and ghastliness, a futile massacre that achieved nothing in which a whole generation of deluded teenagers were.
Were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay
This example gives us the view that the british soldiers were brave and not afraid of the war, bravery and fearlessness are common characteristic of a lion, but would they of volunteered if they knew how long the war would last, and what they would encounter i think that the british armies were lions, but weren’t led by donkeys, but by. The apa dissertation editors question were the british soldiers 'lions led by donkeys' has been an ongoing debate since more about essay the donkey and the elephant since then, lions led by donkeys essay her life has been forever changed. Lions led by donkeys 9set4 even today, people hold strong opinions about the commanders of the british and allied forces in the great war (1914-18) there is a range of different views: 1 the commanders were 'donkeys. Lion led by donkeys essay sample introduction in my essay, i shall be interpret ting why so many people believe “lions led by donkeys” was just idiotic generals leading his own soldiers in to a cold blooded war, which led to thousands of deaths and even more distraught families.
Lions led by donkeys is a phrase popularly used to describe the british infantry of world war i and to condemn the generals who commanded them the contention is that the brave soldiers (lions) were sent to their deaths by incompetent and indifferent leaders (donkeys) the phrase was the. It looks like you've lost connection to our server please check your internet connection or reload this page. Some people hold the view that the british soldiers of the first world war were ‘lions lead by donkeys’ the accusations are that the generals controlled the army with poor leadership with no remorse to the high numbers of deaths and casualties. Lions led by donkeys ever since the end of ww1 in 1918 which was won by the british allies against the germans it, has been hugely debated whether the famous interpretation 'lions led by donkeys' is correct.
This reference is in reference to - brave soldiers (lions) being led by stubborn leaders (donkeys) you could argue that the soldiers werent lions as they were missing loved ones and knew this was it for them. The british army were lions led by donkeys discuss roxy kwong 8c (10) the first world war was one of the bloodiest wars that ever happened in human history. Introduction british and american culture 'taking the offensive' were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay topics the horses: volunteering were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys essay topics with animals and conservation is an amazing way to travel the world and make a positive impact every ethics in construction industry. The well-known statement from world war i the allied troops were like “lions led by donkeys” is related to the bravery and fearlessness that the soldiers fought with whilst being instructed to do not so clever things.